Director
J. Tom Pogue
DIRECTOR
Phoebe Kwong
Justin Lee Stanley
Joel Pincosy
Stars (in credits order)
Tim Hopper
Narrator
Kevin Dwane
Det. Pat Postiglione
Hillary Hamilton
Terri Bowersock
Jessica Desire Love
Simone
Kim Parshley
Detective Jenn Paxson
Terry Mikels
Self - Durham NC Police Department
Christopher Sutphen
Self - Janine's Son
Darren Sutphen
Robin Sutphen
Damian Muziani
Thomas Harrison
Jim E. Chandler
FBI Profiler
Daren Donofrio
Todd
Oryan Landa
Detective Dave Bristow
Brandon J. Shaw
James
Tracilyn Jones
Shauna Tiaffay
Ellie Lee
Jamie
Jason Boyle
Ed Kratzert
Lana Love
Keary
Natalie Jacobs
Concerned Neighbor
Terrence Clowe
Noel
Kathy Harmer
Rita Smith
James Patrick Duffy
Lt. Swiski
Jeffrey Vincent Thompson
Greg Bower
Kevin D. McGee
Police Officer
Mary Goggin
Co worker
Judy Wilson
Danny Wiseman
Detective Mike Denson
Louis Anthony Colello
Cop
Laura Riley
Mary
DeAnna Supplee
Sarai
Gregory Schmunk
Self - Forensic Pathologist
Matthew J. Kaplan
Gregg Schmunck, ME
Cris Colicchio
Robert Brown
Stephanie Vargas
Self - Shauna's Friend
Maggie Hollinbeck
Wendy Kratzert
Maria Wolf
Kristine Fitzhugh
James Feuer
Adam (murder suspect)
James Zeiss
Flirty Casino Guy
Marc Digiacomo
Self - Prosecutor
Christopher Greiner
George Tiaffay
Ginger Fries
Shauna's sister
Barry Golazeski
Self - Former Investigator
Renee Taschner
Self - Former Police Officer
Jesse Evans
Nathan Moffat
Self - Investigator
James Hedrick
Melody Dancy
Self - Devon's Mother
Greg Murphy
Cop - Photographer
Gregory Boer
Fabian Pacheco
William Crouse
Sarai Beague
Self - Marlisa's Friend
Jason Schouten
Dan Long
Richard Finger
Self - Margaret's Son
Mike Denson
Kathleen Jennings
Paula Stokes-Richards
Self - Shauna's Sister
John Hulsing
Self - Sandra's Friend
Self - Loretta's Daughter
Sarah French
Self - Kristine's Friend
Erica Young
Self - Marlisa's Mother
Natalie Poulk
David Kopp
Taw Benderly
Lauren A. Luciano
Maria
Mike Fletcher
James Francis Kellinger
Detective Chuck Chambers
Greg Owen
Self - Wendy's Brother
Charles L. Chambers
Self - Private Investigator
Steve Machita
Joseph Swiski
Robert P. Ruelan
Jimmy Laiaddee
Daniel Scalici
Marlene Buffa
Self - Jamie's Friend
Taylor Lhamon
Darleen Rae Fontaine
Marlisa Wells
Jessica Hendershot
Self - Devon's Friend
Deanna Henson
David's Secretary
Jana Bommersbach
Self - Loretta's Friend
Michael J. Buoni
Ken Fitzhugh
Lauren Lebeouf
Jordan Linn Graham
Dane West
Foster Son
Dina Engel
Sherry
Elizabeth Scopel
Noni
Max MacKenzie
Nate Sullivan
Donal Brophy
Capt. Micheal Machado
Michelle Fitzpatrick
Social Worker
Scott Watson
Mike Dixon
David Cantor
Det. Terry Mikals
Joanna Pinto
Roxy Hulbert
Rich Gentilcore
Task Force Detective
Frank Di Napoli
FBI Agent
Francesca Anderson
Sarah Hulbert
Courtney Jacoby
Lytaunie
Philip Schaefer
Howard Elkins
Michael Simon Hall
Detective Curtis Morris
Dave Morrissey Jr.
Dayton Leroy Rogers
Pat Postiglione
Self - Detective
Michael Carr
Dennis Dixon
Wayne J. Miller
Dwight Tobyne
Molly Gazay
Kim
Abby Lindsay
Shari Tobyne
Marianne Goodell
Cathy
Denise Crisci
Waitress
Weston Whitworth
Policeman
Ira Temchin
Lawrence Kochoa
Jose
Michael Malanga
Cody Lee Johnson
Ted Odell
Robert Petrick
Brian Parpan
Self - Det., Nassau County NY PD (ret.)
Alex Andrews
Prostitute #3
Lukas Max
Hollywood
Joelene Wolfe
Jennifer
Julia Beach
Mrs. Elkins
Vincent Chan
Tech
Nora Maher
Candice Fiore
Marty Whittle
Foster Parent
Franky Tarantino
Lee
Robert Edwards
Self - Det. Sgt., Nassau County NY PD (ret.)
Susan Hedges
Lab Tech
Jennifer Carmichael
Self - Dwight and Shari's Daughter
Cory Clarke
Steve Liss
Self - Former FBI Agent
Kelli Cervantes
Self - Noni's Daughter
Jim Strovink
Self - Retired Detective
James Strovink
Michele Gambino
Funeral Attendee
Rose Marie Bagwell
Self - Tracey's Mother
Jennifer Paxson
Beka Burlak
Prostitute #2
Gabriella Cascio
Maid
Terry Johnson
Hugh Lockerby
Andrejs Eglitis
Self - Retired Deputy District Attorney
Mark Perrone
Det. Allie Roberts
Michael Machado
Oscar Corral
Self - Author, 'Keep Her Contained'
Bruce Barnett
Lytaunie Blasdel
Self - Cody's Friend
Max Realyvasquez
Ben Young III
Tony
Marie Lenzi
Rose Bagwell
Chanel Martin
Self - Tracey's Daughter
Rachel Stephens
Self - Co-Prosecutor
Bridget Hold
Kelli
Curtis Morris
Kimberly Martinez
Self - Jordan's Friend
Roxanna Ferguson
Self - Sara's Sister
Emma Worth
Mrs. D.L. Rogers
Allie Roberts
Kimi Valdivia
Reyna Marroquin
Sandra Lucas
Brenda Terry
Brian Vadim
70's cop
Matt Pasini
Street Kid
Sawyer Ploski
Marcia's friend
Louis Rocky Bacigalupo
Jeffrey Womack
Ceazar Reyes
Undercover Cop
Preston Fritz Smith
Charles Trimble (father)
Marian Edmiston
Detective
Edward M. Kelahan
Sergeant Sherman Nickens
Malcolm Mills
Suspect 3
Carl Fisk
Highlander
Laura Rothschild
Church Elder Ep. 208
Paul Darren Varricchio
Detective Miller
Douglas A. Robbs
Bill Mellen
Detective Jacobs
Kevin E. Murphy
Motorcyle Dealer Manager
Thomas Cambridge
Detective Hefley
Sara F. Wahnish
DNA Lab Tech
Larry Findling
Self - Det., Portland PD (ret.)
Alexis Lundergan
Female Street Kid
John Zimmermann
Self - Former District Attorney
Virginia Trimble Ritter
Self - Marcia's Mother
Teresa Thetford
Self - James's Ex-Wife
Neen Fitzwalter
Self - Harold's (Hal) Sister
Taryn Grey
Virginia Trimble
Zach Myers
James Matheny
Mike Hefley
Robert Moore
Joshua Dye
Steven Pennell (2016)
Charlie Meany
Teacher (2016)
Rebecca Kush
FBI Task Force Leader
Michael Buoni
Ken
Danny Wiserman
Detective Densen
Jeremy Kerr
Sandra's frienduncredited
Frank Sorgenti
Newsy Neighboruncredited
John Cerny
Police Officeruncredited