Director
Justin Wolfe
DIRECTOR
Peter G. Gillespie
Darren Coyle
Stephen Guidry-White
Stars (in credits order)
Russ Harris
Narrator
J. Buzz Von Ornsteiner
Self - Analyst
Matt Gulbranson
Sheriff
Keith Kuperman
Detective
Jesse Robinson
Head Fireman
Vince Eisenson
Neil Woodman
MauraClaire Harford
Brenda Freeman
Erin Nordseth
Maria Marino
Thomas C. McKee
Bullied Kid
Debbie Tsamoudakis
Lori Pond
Tom Gambrill
Husband #3
Karen Dadey
Brookey Lee West
David Clayman
Self - Forensic Psychologist
Sonia Debreczeni
Christine Smith (Middle Age)
Matthew Shea
Jason Befort
Xavier Wolf
Eric Freeman
Katherine Ramsland
Self
Brian Foreman
Peter Chiamardas
Detective Mike Chambers
Dave Ferrier
Gary Matson
Johnna Leary
Mary Stegall
Will Steckman
John
Meg Scanlon
Maria Aquilar
Dallas White
Teenage Danny
Robert Olausen
Deanna Sherman
Vicki Notaro
Aaron Nelson
Derek
Don Whatley
Nick
Sarah Middlemiss
Mrs. Winslow
Jamal Alkhaldi
Duncan Meekins
Darren T. Brown
David
Chaz Riddle
Detective Riddle
Alexis Barone
Young Nancy
Chris A. Wargo
Ed Bowen
Valerie Grace
Vera Woodman
Jesse Milliner
Chris Aldrich
Scott Bruffey
Gary
Tom Schmitt
Young Gary Tison
Colin McHugh
Ward Weaver II
Misti Morningstar
Becky Sears
Ben Ribler
Ward Weaver III
Tracey Allyn
Megan
Jack Heffron
Ward Weaver II Age 11
Amee Walden
Gary Smock's Wife
Christina Carlos
Maria Stout
Dom DiMercurio
Store Clerk
Jodi Stapler
Dorothy Weaver
Arthur Titus
Robert Budrow Jr.
Miranda Robbins
Agatha Ward
James Matthew Poole
Vincent Taragon
Allison Naglieri
Miranda Gaddis
Elijah Lee King
Vernon
Lillie Jewell
Ashley Pond
Gabriela Kostadinova
Randi
Ricky Montano
Cellmate (Wards) informant
Adrian Fernandez
Hitchhicker
Geoffrey Greene
Public Defender
Bonnie Webster
Crack Mom
Josh Reiter
Neighborhood Boy
Donald Imm
Father
Paul H Chapman
Younger Paul Komyatti Sr.
Erin C. Davis
MaryClaire Akers
James Davenjay
Police Officer
Mollye Barrows
Self - Investigative Reporter
Peter Muggleworth
Mikey
Bob Armstrong
Grandfather
Audrey Graziano
Delores Eggert
Richard Adams
Detective Dennis Williams
Samantha Fritter
Tween Keri Allen
William Machuca
Police officer Fishburn
Karn Ford
Mom Post
Henry Hickerson
Adult Ken Allen
Brian Slayton
Brother #1
Mark Ziv
Young Post Brother
Dave Fairbanks
Paul Koymatti Friend
Margaret Perkowski
Teenage Maryann Komyatti
Don Anstock
Greg Hoeller
David Rimmer
Self - Former Prosecutor
Michael Benson
Self - Author
John Sanderson
Self - Investigator
Deidre Milano
Sharon - Mother
Kierra Spruill
Sara Bickler
Monica
Stuart Orloff
Young Joe Post
Ryan Talbot
Young Ken Allen
Joan Crooks
Grandmother
Holly Trout
Adult Keri Allen
Amelia Rose Bennett
Young Keri Allen
Marsha Rehns
Rosemary Komyatti
Steve Gustafso
Officer Hojsik
Allison Howard
Maryann Komyatti
Greg King
Self - Terry King's Brother
Brandon Beecher
Self - Former Ensley Fire Chief
Wayne Ladieu
Self - School Resource Officer
Tim Torre
Henry MacKenzie
Mike Sutton
Dr. William York
Elliott Bales
Det. Dean Sockwell
Gary Ayash
Murder Victim #3
Rachel Klein-Kircher
Valerie Freeman
Pete Garvey
David Gilmore
Aaron Tone
Colonel York
Deirdre McCullagh
Nurse
Sarah Lomke
Monica Fleming
Justyn Christofel
Skinhead
Marisa Tasheuras
Heather Muller
Graham Hooper
Jeffery Howarth
Janelle Schmidt
Kate Bender
Brett Burrier
Andrew Schrieber
Collin Riley
Bryan Freeman
Martha McConnell
Support Group Member
Nate Nelson
Skin Head Leader
Chrislene Bright
Janice Harding
Julie Ann Garvey
Susan Gilmore
Fred Gusoff
Dan Martin
Cody Heuer
Aaron Sander
Joe Pochron
Ben Church
Bender Victim
Steven Wilson Jr.
Reginald Carr
Rene Dechaine
Melissa B. Robinson
Ma Bender
Jack Champion
Young John Reese
Austin Zajur
Sanford Clark
Christopher R. Anderson
Officer Teague
Oakley Bull
Renee's Daughter
Suzanna Woodhead
Paul Reese Sr's Girlfriend
Ariel Myren
Robin
Laura Ruperez
Beth
Ira Grossman
Officer
Sara Torres
Renee Curtis
Ronald Woodhead
Robert Radford
Sammy Smedley
Niki Orvin
Anthony Hackett
George
Reed DeLisle
Wayne
Eliza Kelley
Betty Isaacs
Steven Tyler Foote
Bruce Johnston Jr.
Bianca Allaine
Margene Judge
Todd Bobenrieth
Shanked Prisoner
Jimmy Bacon
Stiner, Jim
Tyler Rush
Christopher Lee Sexton
David Neil Cohen
Husband #1
Lawrence Derx
Sherman McCrary
Alice Bozga
Sherry
Cara Jaye
Convenience Store Clerk
Jennifer Potts
Angela Dante
Jon Musgrave
Self - Historian
Will Dinsmoor
Leslie
Paul Alan Hogan
Gordon Stewart Northcott
Anthony Papastrat
Danny McCrary
Claire Coyle
Jesse Clark
Jason M. Hamel
Cop
Christopher Zash
Glennie Stiles
Rowan Titus
Lana Sexton
Johnny Daly
Norman
Matthew DeHoff
Richard Miller
Benjamin Loeh
Tommy Owens
J.D. Wine
Burtis Taylor
Ian A. Wade
Ricky Mitchell
Demetrius Stephens
Prisoner
Michael Kyne
Construction Worker
John Hawthorne Smith
Undercover Police Officer
Brendan Petak
Willie Sexton
Kevin Leigh
John Lyons
Jason Whitaker
Jack Layne
A.J. Flick
Tom Golian
Damon Bamberg
Cory Cunningham
Young Norman Johnston
Igor Bransteter
John Jarvis
Richard Brown
Camryn Gulbranson
Robin's Friend
Vivian Thompson
Lona Bishop
Madeleine Stevens
Martha
Catie Carlton
Sherri Martin
Delano Walters
Linwood Briley
Noah Sommer
Jimmy Johnston
Loretta Burnette
ACTOR
Randall Gort
Darrell Hill
Ryan Wruble
Lewie Winslow
Aaron Bryant
Raymond Carl Taylor
JD Dan Herbert
Mr. Jenkins
Laura Gepford
Desiree Flowers
Anna Holmes
Jenny
Megan Teresa Flynn
Terri Joe
Jeffery M. Siperly
Chester Dyer
Alexa Kelley
Dawn Stuard
Ian McCleary
Alexis Turrentine
Jordano's Customer
Tim Ciskanik
Billy
Brian Slanger
Dennis Huddle
Leo Rogstad
Prison Guard
Sean Donegan
Young Paul Reese
Lori Titus
School Counselor
Michael Nikolich
Older Raymond Tison
Norman Johnston
John Cangemi
Main Prison Guard
Arthur Kraus
Charles Sexton
Erik Harrison
Kyle Lawrence Price
Young Micajah Harpe
Ronen Lewis
Friend
Jake Taber
Jeffrey Landrigan (Child)
Steven Foote
Bruce Jr.
Anthony Wruble
Nelson Wilson
Steve Frazier
Thomas Langford
Zac Brightbill
Teen Paul Reese
Kelsey Cooper
Betsy Roberts
Billy Saunders Jr.
Melissa Berkowitz
Jena Covey
Melanie Bales
Liz McCrary
Annie K. Fox
Cashier
Marco Di Giuseppe
Renee's Father
Raian Stanley
Wiley Harpe
Lorena Berger
Michelle Sexton
Stacy Gedney
Barbara Reese
Alex Lewis
Young Bruce Jr.
Erin DeCaprio
Mae Sexton
Charlene Smith
Ginger McCrary
Michael Colby
Zachary Scruggs
Joel Good
Cherri Reams
Bertha Briley
Jesse Parish III
Earl Clanton
Max Kelley
Young Brian Reese
Noah Peterson
Forrest Covey
Eddie Fitzgerald
Bag Boy
Traci Dawn
Barry Craig
Alexander Burns
Carl
Stephen Russell
Det. Fanciulli
Josh Kradz
Erik Young
Officer Ben Payton
Jennifer Brown
Sandy Stuard
Marshall Shirley
Paul Reece, Sr
Patrick McCarthy
Ned Alday
Allie Burrier
Leeora Looney
Christie Jackson
Mary Alday
Jillian Kendrick
Tammy McCrary
Austin Burns
Paul Jr.
Brandon Hoover
George Juice Graham
Brian Lyons-Burke
Older Gary Tison
David Hammond
Truck driver
Rachel Chelsea Foster
Stefanie Petrozzino
Brenna Sherman
Young Jennifer
Richard Zane
Cpl. Shriner
Harvey Roberts
State Trooper
Maggie Toomey
Young Karen
Grant Morningstar
Teenage Larry
Joe Barlam
Tony
Andrew James Bleidner
Greg Riffe
Caleigh Anne
Laura Matusiewicz
Bryson Pitts
Little Boy Larry
Vincent Sistrunk
Lawyer
Megan Poppy
Robin Riffe
Chris Stinson
Michael Sears
Justin Sisk
Bobby Petrozzino
Sam McCrea
Tom Matusiewicz
Christopher Reed
Joey Marino
Patrick O'Neal
Michael Roden
Debbie Hartner
Kim Lewis
Glenn Nelson
Undercover Cop
Sandra Belforte
Jake's Mom
Konstantine James
Richard Penardo
Larissa Blair
Older Laura Matusiewitcz
Pawel Grajnert
Austin Katz
Young John
Christine Guerra
Melody Woodman
Frank McAleavey
Loris Rowan
Orlando Gonzalez
James Ray
Anastasia Brunk
Middle Dolores
Shawn Murphy
Detective Pat McCarthy
John Posner
Young James
Benjamin Paul Morris
Detective Gene Donohue
Natalie Cassell
LouEllen George
Jesse N. Davis
Bad Guy
Charlie Titus
Nancy's Son
Liliana Katz
Young Kaitlyn
Derek Martin
Young Neil Woodman
Oakley Moran
Young Joey Marino
Michael Neyland
Young David
Sarah Scheiner
Linda Clark
Eric Evans
Police officer 1
John A. Taylor
Delivery Room Doctor
Fin McCahill
Young Chris
Andrew Gelos
Young William George Sr.
Alex Atwood
Bill Fuss
Kiera Mersky
Desirée Rinker
Bill Halbert
Assistant Detective
Rochelle Weisberger
Vicky
Tony Barber
Billy George
Matthew Snare
Det Brian Harris
Mitchell Cole
David George
Jennifer K. Schultz
Sharon
Gary Davis
John Collins
Thomas Hydock
Young Wayne
Doug Donovan
Denny
Jonathan Meyer
Self Lewis County Prosecutor
Eric Cover
Gordon
Katherine Riddle
Middle Maria Elena
Steven Beverly
Investigator
Jake Kantor
Older Larry
Kaelan Denali Dickinson
Bankteller
Max Klemm
Teenage Billy George
Heather Katz
Confidential Informant
Peter Orvetti
Steve Homick
Janet Devine Smith
Mary Jane
Haley Salyer
Kay Parsons
Chelsea Thaler
Young Mama Maria
Matthew Bernard
Army Buddy #1
David Noffsinger
Witness