Elenco (na ordem dos créditos)
David Holloway
Self - Natalee's Father
Gabriel Madrigal
Self - Informant
John Ludwick
Self - Friend of Joran van der Sloot
TJ Ward
Self - Private Investigator
Eric Bryant
Self - Retired FBI
Katherine Wainscott
Tracy Sargent
Self - Canine Search Handler
Robin Holloway
Self - Natalee's Stepmother
Jason Kolowski
Self - Forensics Expert
Dolphi Richardson
Self - Police Chief
Lauren
Self - John's Girlfriend