Elenco (na ordem dos créditos)
Investigator Kris Coughlin
Rodie Sanchez
Self - Det., Iberville Parish Sheriff's Office (ret.)
Aubrey St. Angelo
Self - Det., Iberville Parish Sheriff's Office
Leslie Bradford
Ronnie Hebert
Self - Major, Iberville Parish Sheriff's Office
Lori Morgan
Jeremy Sanchez
Loda Sanchez
Self - Rodie's Wife
Kathy Fox
Self - Eugenie's Sorority Sister
Joanie Brocato
Self - Louisiana State Police Crime Lab
Brett Stassi
Self - Sheriff, Iberville Parish Sheriff's Office
Zack Simmers
Self - Major, West Baton Rouge Narcotics Division
Kevin Collins
Narrator
Mark Estes
Self - Former Employee of Hagan Fence Company
Lena Richard
Christine Moore's Sister
Bryan White
Self - Major, East Baton Rouge Sheriff's Office
Roger Gunter
ATOR
Tony Clayton
Self - Special Prosecutor
Michael LaPlace
Self - Livingston Parish Sheriff's Office
Mary H. Manhein
Self - Dr., Originally Assigned to Boisfontaine Case, 1997
Ali Fini
Self - Owner, Fini Taxi
Steven Armentrout
Self - Ph.D., Founder and Chief Executive Officer Parabon NanoLabs, Inc.
Mike Sparks
Self - Retired Detective, Rodie's ex-partner
Elizabeth Gomez
Self - Found Eugenie Boisfontaine's Body
Elizabeth Engolio
Self - Assistant District Attorney 18th Judicial District
Eric Wartenweiler Smith
Self - Crime Scene Technician
Thomas Russell
Self - Tipster
Keegan Sanchez
Self - Rodie's Son
Frank Bonifay
Self - Owner, Alligator Bayou Bar
Mike Becnel
Self - Lawnmower Man
Robert Barber
Self
Shannon Thrasher
Self - Suspect
Courtney Simpson
Self - Daughter of Eugenie's Friend
James Grace
Self - Iberville Parish Coroner
Forest Jones
Self - Manager, Hagan Fence
David McDavid
Self - Chief, Zackary Police Department
Curtis Boisfontaine
Self - Eugenie's Brother
Rob Niter
Agent