Elenco (na ordem dos créditos)
Grace Baldridge
Self - Host
Amir Nikoui
Self - Guest
Jack Ruley
Cecilia Betsill
Cassandra Hanks
Elle Kuan
Sara Spadacene
Kempton Baldridge
Brett Erlich
Samantha Schacher
Hasan Piker
Rosalynn Carter
Self - First Lady
Earl Skakel
Karen Kuzma
Self - Sister
Henry Lee
Self
Jay Light
Elizabeth Báthory
Self - Guilty of murdering
James R. Fitzgerald
John Mark Karr
Mike Kane
Self - Former Special Prosecutor, JonBenet Ramsey Case
Barry Boschelli
Self - Childhood Friend
Suzanne Bernhard
Christine Medrano
James Holmes
Self - Big Gamer
Patti Nielson
Self - Art Teacher
Jared Lee Loughner
Helen List
Self - Murder victim
Christian Longo
Self - Murder suspect
Patricia List
Frederick List
Mary Jane Longo
Zachery Longo
Madison Longo
List John Jr.
Sadie Longo