Stars (in credits order)
Eddie Griffin
Self - Host
Loni Love
Self - Judge
Criss Angel
Lance Burton
Angel Rose
Audience Member
Frankie Muniz
Self
Matt Walsh
Corbin Bleu
Michael Ian Black
Miles Brown
Maksim Chmerkovskiy
Vernon Davis
Flavor Flav
Omarion
Ginuwine
Lolo Jones
Jeff Timmons
Saint Anique
Brec Bassinger
Randy Couture
Debbie Gibson
Donny Osmond
Tara Lipinski
Cynthia Bailey
Johnny Weir
Frank Mir