Director
Elliot Goldner
DIRECTOR
Sebastian Smith
Stars (in credits order)
Jeremy Bobb
Narrator
Adeline Roach
Self - Local Resident
Alan Alves
Self - Retired Detective, Freetown PD
Mary Schaefer
Self - Baraboo Resident
Stephanie Allen
Self - Former Perryville Resident
Mark Dzielski
Self - Angola Resident
Mary Ann Pizzolato
Self - Old Town Spring Resident
Stacy Roach
Lee Kirkland
Scott O'Donnell
Self - Executive Director, Circus World
John Brightman
Self - Freetown Resident
Connor Kwilos
Cathy Nance
Self - Local Author
Melody Martin
Mike Kowalski
Kelly Steiner
Henry H. Sweets III
Self - Local Historian
Everette Summers
Luann Joly
Janie Summers
Gary Rush
Shelley Mordini
Jay Gough
Self - Former Old Town Spring Resident
Travis Pike
Kevin Schanbacher
Fran Arnett
Bill Curd
Self - Local Medium
Steve Mordini
James Michael Rice
Anne Sleet
Self - Former Mayor of Perryville
Phill Beith
Ivy Louviere-Dutkiewicz
Jill Otten
Self - Co-owner, Finn's Food & Spirits
Angelika Ramos
B.C. Farr
Pete Bottom
Self - Perryville Resident
René Car
Manny Famolare
Self - Local Paramedic
Ruby Francisco
Lisa Bottom
Jimmy Anderson
Harold Burdick
Tess Corieri-Bronwell
Joe Colossa
Rachael Altgilbers
Mason Winfield
Katie Paulson
Hartman Deetz
Self - Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe Member
Vicki Goode
Andrew Lake
Self - Author and Local Resident
Joseph Mirelez
Self - Owner, Puffabelly's
Bryan Bush
Self - Historian
Carmen Colossa
John Wingate
Self - Author, Lost Boys of Hannibal
Jennifer Kirkland
Self - Perryville Visitor
Matthew McGuirk
Danny Thomas
Denise Hoag
Self - Hoag Boys' Sister
Mark Tully
Joe Tripodi
Self - Caver
Spencer Eskridge
Jack McGuirk
Laura Jones
Self - Former Baraboo Resident
Kate Goode
Marcella Maguire-Boyle
Kathy Brewton
Self - Everette & Janie's Daughter
Ken Marks
Self - Local Shopkeeper
Amelia Cotter
Self - Visitor to Baraboo
Jonathan Montgomery Pollock
Robbie Mayes
Self - Perryville Resident & Historian
Michele Bistany
Bobbie Altiser
Self - Bike Store Owner
Dennis Catencamp
Arif Dagin
Self - Labinnah Bistro Owner
Pat Rickard
Self - Medium
Jeff Sanford
Self - History Enthusiast
Brenda Block
Chris Bobek
Self - Garden House Bed and Breakfast Owner
Chris Dolbeare
Self - Tour Guide, Mark Twain Cave
Perry Foster
Self - Local Psychic
Britney Buckwalter
Self - Psychic Medium
Claire Emmott
Murder Man's Wife(uncredited)
Carl Wharton
Doctor McDowell(uncredited)
Stephen Samson
Soldier(uncredited)
Luke Aquilina
Ghostly Circus Worker(uncredited)
Cameron Bell
Everette(uncredited)
Rebecca Bainbridge
Laura(uncredited)
Lindsay Townley
Civil War surgeon(uncredited)
Matt Truman
Jack Tyler Fisher
Friend(uncredited)
Martin Tomlinson
Mr. Kirkland(uncredited)
Myra Ford
Mary Anne(uncredited)