Director
Patrick Taulère
DIRECTOR
Stars (in credits order)
Mark Krenik
Bill undercover agent
Stuart Todd Martin
Churchgoer
Aundrea Smith
Young Jossie
Scott duPont
Pierce's Partner
Akyra Alihaah Carter
Christina
Andrea L Gavidia
Teenage Christina
Colt Carville
Justin
Jessica Dowdeswell
Dancer
Maralyn Facey
Mother Edna
Chelsea Lorraine Wargo
Laura Finkle
Patrick West
Self - Lead Investigator, North Ridgeville PD
Suzanne Stratford
Self - TV Reporter, WJW News
Danusia Tyburski
Self - Shelly and Hannah's Grandmother
Audrey Jablosnki
Self - Family Friend
Lauren Jablonski
Self - Shelly's Friend
Chelsea Nicol
Greg Petek
Self - Lieutenant, North Ridgeville PD
Jerry Rector
Richard Haltstead
Harvey B. Jackson
NYPD Ofc. Cooke
Alfredo Tavares
Diner Guest
Paige McGarvin
Stephanie Santerre
Jennifer Scibetta
Neighbor
Bri Smith
Sheila Wentzel
Kyle Hancock
Road Worker
Ambyr McWilliams
Jossie Merrifield
Andy Gates
John Parr
Jordan Lawson
Mike Diffens
Cindy Chavez
Patricia
Benjamin Russell
Ernest
Andrew Sykes
Daniel Morrison
Scott Bender
Brian Pinkerton
Connor Keene
David Greene
Tyrone Van Tatenhove
Adult Fred
Deanne Lauvin
Lawrence's Wife
Haley Gauthier
Lisa Finkle
Paula Jay Fairbrother
Patricia's Mother
Chris Paseka
CPS Agent
Sean Leo
Teenage Michael
Chase Victoria
Young & Adult Ana
Atticus Nations
Young Harry
Bryan Hanna
Mickey Freed
Loretta Shenosky
Nosey Neighbor
Dan Cheatham
Leroy Wentzel
Alex Campbell Stein
Jim Horton
Mark Schaefer
Detective Irmin Pierce
David John Kernick
Detective Jonathan Jacobs
Tomas Johansson
Coroner
Beverley Simmons
Young Edna
Mary Lou Matthews
District Attorney
Molly Dougherty
Adult Mary
Jenni Wilson
Sharon Halstead
Nicole Sacharow
Heather Santerre
Jim Marshall
Tex Shively
Cooper Foster
Sandy
Marilia Colturato
Carol Finkle
Amelia Jakovich
Young Lisa
Rachel Hunt
Charlene Parr
Brynnleigh Spens
Teenage Sheila
Daz Byard
Peter Finkle
Jonathan Brenner
Derek
Shanai Erdem
Gail Bullen
Leslee Crisman
Janelle
Erik Friestad
Greg
Braiden Neven
Nathaniel Greene
Matthew Last
Leo Halstead
Brett Chapin
Cop #1
Susan Touchbourne
Female Neighbor
Abrielle Cummings
Young Laura
Jensen Chambers
Young Frederick Brown
Olivia de Boutray
Sabra
Denice Riddle
Eileen Haltstead
Lisa Cody
Janelle's Mom
Jamie Mendoza
Police Officer
Amari Chala
Young Sandra
Shen Yue
Simone Verellen
Casey O'Keefe
Betty Jo Fowler
Mason Blomberg
Young Lonnie
Briella Guiza
10 year old Dorothy
Tim Parrish
DJ Jimmy D
Danny McFarland
Donald Cook
Tom Wade
Kevin Curtis
Matthew Campbell
Darren Kendrick
Nick
Julyah Rose
Judith
Tatiana Turan
Vivian Miranda
Claire Montgomery
Frail Mary
Rinnan Henderson
Dorthea Beck
Christine Liao
Josephine
Luke Matheis
Policeman #1
Kimberley Wintle
Dora
Brady Carville
Ford
David Garber
John Verellen
Sun Park
Simone
Taryn Leggett
Theresa Fowler
Kenny Pollone
Jason
Scott Stewart
Emergency Room Doctor
Marik Knight
Alan Flower
Tina Kobas
D.A Janet Albertson
Sarah Marie Casey
Karen
R Scott Hoffman
Angry Truck Driver
Hilary Matkovich
Eve
Merlynda Sol
Sharon
David Scott
Bruce Raticoy
Beverly Rose
Young Linda
James M Tweedie
Stepdad
Natalie Johnson
Janet
Emily Angela
Young Diane
Shawn Pan
Robert Henley Starr
Lonnie Fowler
Marcelina Kalet
Janece Cook (2019)
Jordan Carlson
Roxanne Ortega
Nicole Gilbert
Diane Hart
Lilly Harrison
Adult Janet
Tanner Larsen
Young Duane
Rachel Anne Roy
Serena Miranda
Sean Walters McDonald
Young Stephan
Olivia Berger
Erin
Anjella Guiza
10 year old Mary
Chloe Marie Hart
Young Vicki
Noam Feig
Donald Cook (Teen)
Jordan O'Connell
Charity Miranda
Blake Seltzer
Detective Chris Sullivan
Madison Sepulveda
Young Angela
Ilyse Sherman
Elizabeth Miranda
Caty Gordon
Jamie
Michael Enkhtaivan
Quan
Rachel Jalving
Tina Ewell
Sherre Gilbert
Self
Yo Ying
Cassidy Gatlin
Ashley M.
Allie McCarthy
Ashley Garrison
Brie Tilton
Debra
Ava Guttmann
Young Hananh
Victoria Kelemen
Teenage Brandi
Johana Vasková
Sherre Gilbert young
Macie Pinzone
Cary Christopher
Coleuncredited
Beatrice Ring
Forensic Agentuncredited
Gaia Passaler
Adult Shellyuncredited
Paul Anthony Turner
Darrell Tyburskiuncredited
Avery Eletto
Young Shellyuncredited
Eloy Perez
SGT. Patrick Westuncredited
Mara Swanson
Chelseauncredited