Baking Up Love (2021) | Full Cast

Candice T. Cain

DIRECTOR

Michael Bonini

Peter Menold

Stefanie Bloom

Madison Bell

Jason Frederick

Pierce Morton

Katelin Stack

Mae Kaufman

David Otunga

Coach Robison

Alix Kermes

Lynn Travis

Ivana Grahovac

Brooke Remington

Kenney Myers

Mayor Jeff Kaufman

Jeff Timmons

Pastor Mark

Carly Bondar

Miss Hamlin

Catherine Cain

Julie Remington

Delilah Hefner

Church Goer

Gary Metivier

Jake Reilley

Tia Howell

Bake-Off Attendee

Jessica Lee Andres

Morgan

Kimberly Hart

Mortonite

Todd Wilderman

Mortonite

Monika Mannix

Bake-Off Competitor

Steve Christopher

Mr. Coburn

Allison Grischow

Lulu Davis

Dana Hobson

Mortonite

David Otunga Jr.

Ray

Tierza Scaccia

Amy Price

Missy Byrd

Desiree

Kaity Jones

Bake-Off Attendee

Sarah Albrecht

Church Goer

Aleah Kennell

Mortonite

Laketa Caston

Mrs. Franklin

Dylan Cruz

Mr. Penedo

Marilyn Roberts

Bake-Off Finalist

Katie Schaefer

Mortonite

Carey Beckerdite

The Confectionery Customer

Tony Feleccia

Church-Goer

Angela Sommer

Ball Attendee

Ava Siems

Mortonite

Heather Towell

Bake-Off Attendee

Sophia Daugherty

Mortonite

Natalya Dillard

Ball Attendee

Bryan Cobert

Church Goer

Rebecca Saxsma

Mortonite

Michele Hefner

Church-Goer

Kassidy Stolba

Ball Attendee

Thomas Luft

Mortonite

Brooke Humbles

Bake-Off Attendee

Cameron McKimmey

Mortonite

Ella Headley

Lulu's On Main Customer

Christina Zobrist

Bake-Off Attendee

Lola Kaiser

Bake-Off Attendee

Wynter Otunga

Tipsy's Customer

Erin R. Jones

Tipsy's Customer

Nancy Luchtefeld

Bake-Off Competitor

Kenna Bethel

The Confectionery Customer

Stephanie Rosenthal

Mortonite

Daniel Sutter

Mortonite

Brooke Schuler

Church Goer

Emily Schaefer

Mortonite

Shawna Farris

Mortonite

Emma Beyer

Church-Goer

Diana Hoffman

Church-Goer

Brianna Bohling

Mortonite

Emma Turner

Mortonite

Morghan Silotto

Mortonite

Rhonda Kaufman

Mortonite

Kenedi Gordon

Mortonite

Lesley Thomson

Mortonite

Angelia L. DeWeese

Bake-Off Attendee

Calli Gordon

Mortonite

Steve Schwetman

Shane Sanders

Ava Kaufman

Catering Waitress

Sherry Cooper

Bake-Off Attendee

Keeley Wonsowski

The Confectionery Customer

Kendra Bailey

Ball Attendee

Neeki Aghaei

Mortonite

Gaby Heer

Bake-Off Attendee

Chad Taylor

Timothy Flame

Rosalie Glasson

Mortonite

Jill Williamson

Bake-Off Competitor

Bailey Martin

Ball Attendee

Lexi Sherman

Bake-Off Attendee

Teagan Ealey

Bake-Off Attendee

Amelia Chatwell

Mortonite

Amanda Litwiller

Mortonite

Dawn Barnes

Mortonite

Zach Hoffmire

Church-Goer

Allayna Hart

Bake-Off Attendee

Taryn Collins

Mortonite

Kimberly L. Johnson

The Confectionery Customer

Taylor Rogers

Bake-Off Competitor

Danielle Sanders

Mortonite

Austin Simpson

Mortonite

Ron Hanselman

Mortonite

Shaylee Mae Rumbold

Mortonite

R. Gail Welsh

Tipsy's Customer

Jodi Smith

Ball Attendee

Samantha Tomsovic

Mortonite

Kate Wilderman

Mortonite

Alyssa Napolitano

Mortonite

Maverick Hillman

Mortonite

Jeff Kaufman II

Bake-Off Competitor

Royce Robinson

Lulu's On Main Customer

Sharon Thoma

Bake-Off Attendee

Courtney Hodel

Bake-Off Competitor

Keegan Anderson

Mortonite

Lillian Richardson

Mortonite

Jodi Smith

Ball Attendee

Walter Block

Bake-Off Attendee

Kristina Galligan

Mortonite

Jayden Defreitas

Mortonite

Andrew Von Ahnen

Bake-Off Announcer

Avery McKune

Mortonite

Alexandria Martin

Ball Attendee

Sara Lopko

Mortonite

Shannon McClure

Bake-Off Attendee

Julie Ackerman

Mortonite

Katie Beckerdite

Bake-Off Attendee

Krista Bethel

The Confectionery Customer

Lillian Cobert

Church Goer

Misikir Kaufman

Bake-Off Volunteer

Naomi Steffen

Mortonite

Emma Cochran

Mortonite

Michael Rosenthal

Mortonite

Jacqueline Schwarzentraub

Tipsy's Customer

Tammy Beyer

Church-Goer

Harlow Sharum

The Confectionery Customer

Esther Rosenboom

Church Goer

Karen Loudermilk

Bake-Off Attendee

Sally Brock

Mortonite

Colin R. Jones

Tipsy's Customer

Carrie Bade

Mortonite

Molly Shook

Mortonite

Grady Loudermilk

Bake-Off Volunteer

Cyrenius Sutter

Mortonite

Madison Harris

Bake-Off Attendee

Robyn Ekstam

Mortonite

Elena Cordoba

Mortonite

Melissa Reineke

Lulu's On Main Customer

Dean Ekstam

Mortonite

Catherine Sadler

Mortonite

Casey Hoffmire

Bake-Off Attendee

Luke Kunz

Mortonite

Katelyn Mason

Mortonite

Phill Wilderman

Mortonite

Barbara Polk

Mortonite

Ryan Schaub

Mortonite

Barbara McMullen

Mortonite

Alexandra Martin

Ball Attendee

Zakeri Eidson

Ball Attendee

Wendy J. Vastine

Church Goer

Patricia Goeken

Mortonite

Mark Powell

Mortonite

Kurt Smith

The Confectionery Customer

Lorilyn Jones

Yummy Yummy Bakery Finalist

Melissa Linboom

Mortonite

Rylli Koener

Ball Attendee

Maisy Collins

Mortonite

Karen Sommer

Ball Attendee

Lucy Weeks

Bake-Off Attendee

Kaydin Moore

Ball Attendee

Addyson Gallup

Mortonite

Abigail Gasper

Mortonite

Theresa Duncan

Mortonite

Sam Smith

The Confectionery Customer

Beth Headley

Lulu's On Main Customer

Marley Leman

Bake-Off Attendee

Mikayla Mathis

Bake-Off Attendee

Keaton Weber

The Confectionery Customer

Elliotte Howell

The Confectionery Customer

Taylor Myers

Bake-Off Attendee

Camp Akers

Bake-Off Attendee

Jessie Yoder

Mortonite

Joel Getz

Bake-Off Attendee

Heather Luft

Mortonite

Katherine Mulvey

Mortonite

Jeffrey G. Durand

Bake-Off Attendee

Paige Malson

Bake-Off Attendee

Chris Robinson

Lulu's On Main Customer

Nicholas Darcy

Mortonite

Jeannie Dicks

Bake-Off Attendee

Jennifer Donovan

The Confectionery Customer

Alivia Holman

Ball Attendee

Ben Towell

Bake-Off Attendee

Sharon Hill

The Confectionery Customer

Margery Rosenthal

Mortonite

Brittany Burk

Ball Attendee

Scott LeMasters

Church-Goer

Sandy Glover

Mortonite

Terry R. Hill

The Confectionery Customer

Julie Weeks

Bake-Off Attendee

Diann Kamp

Ball Attendee

Beau Kaufmann

Bake-Off Attendee

Laike Sadler

Bake-Off Attendee

Amanda Marks

The Confectionery Customer

Haley Sauder

Mortonite

Breanna Hamilton

Bake-Off Attendee

Brittany Long

Mortonite

Joseph Estes

Church-Goer

Jamie Schick

Bake-Off Attendee

Leland Sumer

Ball Attendee

Tony Eddy

The Confectionery Customer

Nikki Cantu

The Confectionery Customer

Maggie Hobson

Mortonite

Morgan Smith

Ball Attendee

Natalie Hoffmire

Church-Goer

Mary Fisher

Ball Attendee

Maghan McMenamin

Mortonite

Marie LaHood Arendell

Mortonite

Cydney Hosey

Mortonite

Addison Allen

Bake-Off Attendee

Kara Knepp

The Confectionery Customer

Glen Lipe

Mortonite

Mikenna Mathis

Ball Attendee

Noah White

Mortonite

Ashley Sauder

Mortonite

Ella Estes

Church-Goer

Kellie Ferguson

Lulu's On Main Customer

Janet Powers

Mortonite

Frankie Mustari

Mr. Wilson

Sandra Burrier

Bake-Off Attendee

Carli Taufer

The Confectionery Customer

Matthew Schaefer

Mortonite

Katrina Chatwell

Mortonite

Paige Chapin

Mortonite

Tira Aghaei

Mortonite

Staci Petersen

Mortonite

Ashlyn Reaktenwalt

Church Goer

Caleb Manthey

Ball Attendee

Savanna Carey

Mortonite

Quinn Rinkenberger

Mortonite

Peter Grant

Bake-Off Attendee

Courtney Englund

Tipsy's Customer

Maria Lopko

The Confectionery Customer

Delaney Maher

The Confectionery Customer

Brenda Robinson

Lulu's On Main Customer

Amy Robinson

Mortonite

Lily Stephens

Mortonite

Seth Randolph

Mortonite

Kenneth Hess

Bake-Off Attendee

Angie Petri

The Confectionery Customer

Ethen Glasson

Mortonite

Amelia Holman

Ball Attendee

Meredith Ambrosia

Mortonite

Todd M. Beyer

Church-Goer

Adelle Worthy

Mortonite

Susan Railey

Tipsy's Customer

Virginia Mathis

Mortonite

Daurice Coaster

The Confectionery Customer

Quinn Weber

The Confectionery Customer

Tracy Aghaei

Mortonite

Timothy Cooper

Mortonite

Jeanne Gardner

Mortonite

Michael Dorsey

Bake-Off Attendee

Josette Orlevitch

Church-Goer

Amy Petersen

Mortonite

Landon Roemersberger

Mortonite

Kylie LeMasters

Church-Goer

Allison Milby

Ball Attendee

Ishmael Paulino

Bake-Off Competitor

Carter Parrott

Bake-Off Attendee

Kylie Hayden

Bake-Off Attendee

Dan Getz

Bake-Off Attendee

Lucy Kaufman

Rebecca Curry

Landon Polk

Mortonite

Grace Simmons

The Confectionery Customer

Makenna Polk

Mortonite

Susana Plumier

Tipsy's Customer

Macy Meiss

Mortonite

Laura Cordoba

Mortonite

Morgan Glasson

Mortonite

Kathleen VanMieghem

Mortonite

Travis Langenbach

Shawn Schmidt

Brenda Kaiser

Bake-Off Attendee

Eugene Bracy

Security Guard

Juliana Beckerdite

Bake-Off Attendee

Shaun Bollenbach

Bake-Off Attendee

Shawn Siems

Mortonite

Cherissa Hoffman

Mortonite

Jaclyn Whitlock

The Confectionery Customer

Katherine Bauman

The Confectionery Customer

Victoria Schacht

Mortonite

Adalyn Sanders

The Confectionery Customer

Harrison Jeffries

Mortonite

Alivia Schacht

Mortonite

Elizabeth Siron

Mortonite

Aletia Keltner

Mortonite

James Julah

Bake-Off Attendee

Molly Loudermilk

Bake-Off Attendee

Ashley Geil

Bake-Off Attendee

Liz McCauley

Pastor Mark's Wife

Christopher Gruel

Mortonite

Jared Taylor

Mortonite

Christian Harris

Bake-Off Attendee

Edwin Ed Thoma

Bake-Off Finalist

Heather Loudermilk

Bake-Off Attendee

Brian Hoffman

Ball Attendee

Brad Petersen

Mortonite

Afton Sutter

Mortonite

Sage Bollenbach

Bake-Off Attendee

Craig Loudermilk

Executive

Tate Darcy

Mortonite

Shelli Jarvis

Ball Attendee

Rod Blunier

Executive

Mary Holmgren

Bake-Off Attendee

Bridget Joos

Mortonite

Jenny Roche

Bake-Off Finalist

George Burrier Jr.

Bake-Off Attendee

Anna Werries

Bake-Off Attendee

Brendan Englund

Tipsy's Customer

Laketa Caston

Mrs. Franklin

Jason Beckerdite

Bake-Off Attendee

Brynleigh Vance

Tipsy's Customer

Daniel Walker

Bake-Off Attendee

Madeline Kraft

Mortonite

Cadence Headley

Lulu's On Main Customer

Grace Osborne

Mortonite

Curtis Boyer

Mortonite

Jean Hansen

Bake-Off Attendee

Melanie Nickerson

Lulu's On Main Customer

Matthew Sheehan

Bake-Off Attendee

David Trillizio

Bake-Off Attendee

Asanta Cunningham

Mortonite

Key Doll Hoffmire

Church-Goer

Aubrey Werries

Bake-Off Attendee

Jen Witzig

Mortonite

Chris Jacobson

Bake-Off Attendee

Alexia Derr

Bake-Off Attendee

Sarah Irwin

Lulu's On Main Customer

Melissa Hoffmire

Church-Goer

Samantha Wilderman

Mortonite

Tracy Zimmerman

Mortonite

Nolan Valz

The Confectionery Customer

Lori Crumrine

Church Goer

Grace Shelton

Bake-Off Attendee

Ehrica Dorsey

Bake-Off Attendee

Kimberly Bright

The Confectionery Customer

Cynthia Villa

Mortonite

Kaitlin Klopfenstein

Lulu's On Main Customer

Kaci M. Gordon

Mortonite

Reese Chapin

Mortonite

Gabriella Juarez

Emily

Debbie Rizzo

The Confectionery Customer

Andrew Jordan

Mortonite

Lena Oswald

Mortonite

Addison Wilson

Church-Goer

Michael Simms

Mortonite

Marisa Williamson

Bake-Off Attendee

Sarah Fore

Mortonite

Steven Mueller

Mortonite

Ronda Sherrill

Deputy Mayor's Wife

Payton Roche

Mortonite

Jeffrey L. Kaufman

Deputy Mayor

Brianna Bloom

Bake-Off Competitor

Steven Freeze

Church-Goer

Layne Kaufman

Bake-Off Volunteer

Patty Jones

Tipsy's Customer

Lindsay McMullen

Mortonite

Katherine Cobert

Church Goer

Rylan E. Jones

Tipsy's Customer

Milo Kaiser

Bake-Off Attendee

Rose M. Durand

Bake-Off Attendee

Jamie Burk

The Confectionery Customer

Macy Skinner

Bake-Off Attendee

Mackenzie Innis

Mortonite

Honey Overholt

Ball Attendee

Cheryl Langenbach

Mortonite

Emily Schumacher

The Confectionery Customer

Michael Eeten

The Confectionery Customer

Kathy Diehl

Mortonite

Kate Schuler

Church Goer

Jacqueline Powers

Tipsy's Customer

Shaun Elias

The Confectionery Customer

Jacqueline Austin

Mortonite

Emery Robinson

Lulu's On Main Customer

Casey McWhirter Iii

The Confectionery Customer

Dulcinea Sutter

Mortonite

Betsy Cooper

Mortonite

Kaitlin Bollenbach

Bake-Off Attendee

Josie Weidner

Tipsy's Customer

Douglas B. Hanselman

Mortonite

Tinley Petri

The Confectionery Customer

John Battioli

Mortonite

Clara Young

Ball Attendee

Sylvia Steffen

Mortonite

Marci Tewksbury

Mortonite

Jaylin Paige Rumbold

Mortonite

Gary Beall

Bake-Off Attendee

Eleanor Lynx Bush

Mortonite

Katrina M. Gehman

Mortonite

Dawn Tuley

Ball Attendee

Ashly Stephens

The Confectionery Customer

Carter Stephens

The Confectionery Customer

Lane Mannino

The Confectionery Customer

Jamie Carriere

Mortonite

Leigh Ann Brown

Mortonite

Elliott Kindred

Mortonite

Margaret McFeeters

Bake-Off Attendee

Laney Dawson

Church Goer

Caitlin McWhirter

The Confectionery Customer

Angel Fisher

Bake-Off Attendee

Kayley Tanner

Bake-Off Competitor

Christine Phillips

The Confectionery Customer

Tara Althoff

The Confectionery Customer

Cali Fitzgerald

Mortonite

Nate Parrott

Bake-Off Attendee

Jackson Weber

The Confectionery Customer

Ben Ackerman

Mortonite

Mark Getz

Bake-Off Attendee

Brittany Wolfe

The Confectionery Customer

Sarah Powers

Church Goer

Heather Swick

Lulu's On Main Customer

Brandy Bessler

The Confectionery Customer

Charlie Farris

Bake-Off Attendee

Klair Bethel

The Confectionery Customer

Bella Worthy

Mortonite

Drake Seibert

Mortonite

Henley Grace Pyle

Lacey Williams

Renee Huschen

Tipsy's Customer

Andrew Schaub

Mortonite

Juliette Marotta

Bake-Off Finalist

Alaine Robinson

Lulu's On Main Customer

Tracy Cole

Church Goer

Tillie Kaiser

Mortonite

Laura Craig

Bake-Off Competitor

Jeff Kaufman Iii

Mortonite

Adelynn Holman

Ball Attendee

Joshua Knight

Mortonite

Elijah Rosenboom

Church-Goer

Pamela Gage

Ball Attendee

Jamie Skinner

Bake-Off Attendee

Holly Dawson

Church Goer

Chris Farris

Bake-Off Attendee

Craig Janssen

Nathan Gray

Ann Kamp

Mortonite

Jennifer Haniff Thompson

Ms. Patel

Smith T.J.

Mortonite

Allison Nicole Smith

Bake-Off Attendee

Jessica Belsly

Mortonite

Keegan Vance

Tipsy's Customer

Allison Werries

Bake-Off Attendee

Jackson Stephens

The Confectionery Customer

Rachel Waterfield

Bake-Off Attendee

Hannah Albrecht

Church Goer

Wendi Lyn Rumbold

The Confectionery Customer

Sarah Honegger

Mortonite

Melissa Bollenbach

Bake-Off Attendee

Jayci Arganbright

Ball Attendee

Sophie Whring

Bake-Off Attendee

Kylie Klopfenstein

Bake-Off Attendee

Keely Cooper

Mortonite

Lydia Rosenboom

Church-Goer

Lisa Moser

Mortonite

Melinda Reeter

Mortonite

Julie Losen

Bake-Off Attendee

Alex Chaikin

Mortonite

Christy Siemon

Mortonite

Erinn Reising

Mortonite

Debra Deiss

The Confectionery Customer

Holly Howell

The Confectionery Customer

Casondra Wertzler

The Confectionery Customer

Jacqueline Montgomery

Ball Attendee

Jennifer Foley

Mortonite

Kyla Neal

Ball Attendee

Ashley Maurer

Tipsy's Customer

Bruce Hoffmire

Church-Goer

Abigail Luft

Mortonite

Allen Derr

Bake-Off Attendee

Jessica Karpawicz

Executive

Arlie Akers

Bake-Off Attendee

Doug Witzig

Mortonite

Clinton Robison

Bake-Off Finalist

Aimee Siems

Mortonite

Dacia Le

Mortonite

Joey Jeffries

The Confectionery Customer

Daxton Ambrosia

Mortonite

Katie Krupa

The Confectionery Customer

Brett Thomson

Mortonite

Cody Kaufman

Morton's Favorite Dog

Scott Pyle

Bake-Off Attendee

Candice Tennell

The Confectionery Customer

Collin Weigle

Bake-Off Attendee

Kaelyn Nash

Mortonite

Becki Davis

Church Goer

Scott A. Nickerson

Mortonite

Stacy Schuler

The Confectionery Customer

Myleigh Gage

Church-Goer

Mitch Holmgren

Mortonite

Bridget England

Tipsy's Customer

Haley Detloff

Mortonite

Amanda Pyle

Bake-Off Attendee

Scott Witzig

The Confectionery Customer

Jeremy Short

Bake-Off Attendee

Jennifer Fifer

The Confectionery Customer

Rachel Elias

The Confectionery Customer

Phillip Gardner

Mortonite

Justin Cochran

Mortonite

Lexi Loudermilk

Mayor's Daughter

Aileen Holman

Ball Attendee

Anna M. Hopkins

Mortonite

Oliver Irior

Ball Attendee

Kaeden Althoff

The Confectionery Customer

Kadee Allenbaugh

Black Swan Bakery Finalist

Raegan Knepp

The Confectionery Customer

Trevor Dare

Mortonite

Mark Bischoff

Lulu's On Main Customer

Alice Goeken

Mortonite

Cathy LaHood Kouri

Mortonite

Evelyn Mulvey

Mortonite

Dalton Mueller

Mortonite

Lisa Singleton

The Confectionery Customer

Barbara Carraway

Bake-Off Attendee

Stephanie Lichtenberg

Bake-Off Attendee

Denise Spreeman

Church-Goer

Hazel Gardner

Mortonite

Sophia Kaufmann

Bake-Off Attendee

Janice Shafer

The Confectionery Customer

Colin Burk

The Confectionery Customer

Ashley Maurer

Tipsy's Customer

Joshua Ackerman

Mortonite

Carl Hoffmire

Church-Goer

Susan Pyles

The Confectionery Customer

Jacey Dean

Mrs. DeFriest

Mary Jane Nohl

Bake-Off Attendee

Melissa Klumb

Bake-Off Attendee

Abby Towell

Bake-Off Attendee

Caitlin Dillard

The Confectionery Customer

Keli Wagner

Ball Attendee

Justin Hoffman

Mortonite

Mark Schuler

The Confectionery Customer

Alex Mueller

Mortonite

Jenna McCartney

Mortonite

Brad Rice

The Confectionery Customer

Emily Crumrine

Church Goer

Melissa Allen

Bake-Off Attendee

Baley Thrasher

Church-Goer

Brenda Kleinert

The Confectionery Customer

Jennifer Smith

The Confectionery Customer

Daniel Austin

Mortonite

Avriel Ambrosia

Mortonite

Adam Smith

Lulu's On Main Customer

Tate Kaiser

Bake-Off Attendee

Dennis Medley

Bake-Off Attendee

Tabitha Floyd

Bake-Off Attendee

Ava Rose Bonham

Mortonite

Logan Barnard

Ball Attendee

Iris Kaufman

Bake-Off Attendee

Ashley Schreck

Ball Attendee

Pres Malson

Bake-Off Attendee

Eli Joos

Mortonite

Peg Sauder

Executive

Abigail McKinley

The Confectionery Customer

Lynn Langenbach

Vin Pain Chocolat Bakery Finalist

Kelly Albrecht

Church Goer

Allison Vastine

Church Goer

Megan Ackerman

Mortonite

Sullivan Gaskill

Mortonite

Ivy Taufer

The Confectionery Customer

Michelle Short

Bake-Off Attendee

Wells Gaskill

Mortonite

Silas Steffen

Mortonite

Christian Schlehuber

Mortonite

Hayden Sadler

Bake-Off Attendee

Pamela S. Hillyard

Bake-Off Attendee

Holly-Anne Geier

Bake-Off Attendee

Jarrett Polk

Mortonite

Jeff Yontz

Mortonite

Lily Smith

Ball Attendee

Sam Austin

Mortonite

Tabitha Gage

Church-Goer

Seven Figgers

The Confectionery Customer

Laurie Werries

Bake-Off Attendee

Caitlyn Cooper

Bake-Off Attendee