Oneonta Road (2004)

When several young girls go missing in the small upstate town of Oneonta, New York, detectives Frank Beamer (Eric Berner) and Amanda Jeffers (Ashley Sheehan) investigate a remote gas station with a morbid secret in the basement. Timothy Blevins (David Kinnaird), whose father owns the store, seems to be hiding a disturbing lifestyle, unbeknownst to his own parents.