Director
Sean Michael Beyer
DIRECTOR
Stars (in credits order)
Kevin G. Schmidt
Jeff Pryce
Pamela Jean Noble
Mary
Sally Kirkland
Lois
Kristin Herrera
Karen
Richard Riehle
Detective Mahoney
Sean Marquette
Curtis
Charlie Schlatter
Detective Richards
Kyle Davis
Peter Johnson
Lauren Storm
Erica
Dustin Dugas Schuetter
Kevin
Janet Rotblatt
Old Mary
Robert Stack
Self (archiveFootage)
Rachel Elizabeth Ames
Officer Carter
Mikel Arvizu
Officer Baker
Guy Barile
Unsolved Taxi Driver
Joanne Baron
Jeff's Therapist (voice)
Conn Barrett
Clerk
Shelley Boozer
Undercover Cop
Tara Chocol
Unsolved Mary
Larry Davis
Homecoming Dance DJ
Lia Fietz
Girl in cemetery
Daniel Friedman
Homecoming Dance Chaperone
Jeremy A. Levin
Young Detective
Zach Matchem
Bob
Christiana Minga
Homecoming Dance Date
Michael Pashan
Arrested Guy
Kevin Schlanser
Teddy
Palmer Scott
Minister
Samantha Valencia
Girl at Party
Jude S. Walko
Bible Salesman
Nermin Zajic
Jeff at 12
Rita Zajic
Jeff's Mom
Julia Faye West
Dancer
Sarah Chang Tadayon
Girl Dancer (uncredited)